About Mediation Solutions of NY

Our Founding

Before the COVID-19 pandemic, it could take 3 or more years between the time a civil case was filed and the time it reached the trial calendar, and possibly an additional year before it was heard. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, that backlog of cases has only increased, making it more difficult for attorneys and their clients to get their cases resolved.

5 people posing for a portrait in glass building with Plants in the background
Mediation Solutions of NY Founders Nancy Burner, Michael Levine, Allison Johs, Fred Johs, and A. Gail Prudenti

Attorneys Frederick C. Johs, Hon. A. Gail Prudenti, Michael Levine, Nancy Burner, and Allison C. Johs know firsthand from their many years of law practice and on the bench that clients become increasingly frustrated the longer their cases go unresolved. Even where the parties had already agreed to mediation or arbitration, it could take months to receive a hearing date. Knowing that litigants in Suffolk County had no local options for alternative dispute resolution, we formed Mediation Solutions of NY, LLC. with the intention of providing mediation and arbitration services for attorneys and their clients from the east end of Long Island to New York City.

In short, Mediation Solutions of NY was created by lawyers for lawyers to help them get cases resolved right in their own backyards.

Our Commitment

Conflict is hard. We make it easier. Mediation Solutions of NY, LLC builds bridges between opposing parties in legal and business disputes to achieve results and settlements without court intervention.

Our team will work with you to accomplish the results you and your clients deserve in a timely and efficient manner whether your matter is simple or complex. If you have a business dispute, personal injury or medical malpractice case, estates and trusts/surrogate’s court matter, tax certiorari claim, or other conflict, you deserve an organization with mediators and arbitrators you can trust to help you reach a fair resolution.

But don’t just take our word for it – hear what lawyers are saying about working with Mediation Solutions:

I recently mediated a case, pre-litigation, with a demand of $450,000 and no offer using Judge Condon as the mediator. In less than an hour and a half we were very close to settling, which ultimately happened. This was a unique case, with an untested new law and very interesting legal and factual issues and lots of emotion. Couldn’t have settled without the assistance of Mediation Solutions. Very reasonable fee structure too.

Mark Goldsmith, Jakubowski, Robertson, Goldsmith & Tartaglia, LLP

I just completed a settlement day at Mediation Solutions of NY and this was my first opportunity to utilize their services. It was a very successful day in terms of resolving difficult cases. My client, who was in attendance from out of state was equally happy with the results of the day. Judge Condon was an extremely effective mediator whose style was well received by all sides. Diane Clancy and the staff made scheduling easy. Diane and the IT department were extremely accommodating throughout the day to ensure that everything ran smoothly. The facilities are also top-notch and very comfortable for all.

Gary Muhlstock, Cullen & Dykman, LLP

I had never heard of this mediation company before but a carrier on a difficult case said they would pay if I used a particular mediatior, a former judge from Suffolk County, William Condon, on my New York County case. I was very skeptical but they would not agree to my choices. So I checked around and I was told Judge Condon ‘gets’ plaintiffs, he was fair, and he understood what values outside of Suffolk were. The mediation company also had quick dates with him as we were close to trial and needed speed. They were very responsive and made things happen quickly. True to form the mediator was straightforward and direct but not pushy and his numbers were not wrong. We settled for a fair number and I would use the Judge and Mediation Solutions again.

Wade T. Morris, Esq.

Our Core Values

  • Integrity
  • Exceptional Dispute Resolution Professionals
  • Customer Service
  • Timely Results

Our Mediators and Arbitrators

Mediation Solutions of NY, LLC is committed to providing you with the highest quality alternative dispute resolution experience. To that end, we have chosen only those judges and practitioners of the highest integrity to arbitrate or mediate your cases. Each of our neutrals has earned the respect of their peers and has a reputation for fairness and for resolving cases swiftly and effectively. When you choose to arbitrate or mediate your case with Mediation Solutions of NY, LLC, you can rest assured that your matter will receive the attention it deserves and that we will do our utmost to build a bridge between the parties to achieve a resolution.

See our panel of distinguished neutrals.

Convenient Locations

Pink glass windowed building
Main Office
Glass building
1377 Motor Parkway, Islandia, NY

Our main office is conveniently located just off of the Long Island Expressway at Exit 57 in a professional, A+ rated building on Motor Parkway in Islandia, New York. Our facility offers four modern and comfortable conference rooms to conduct in-person and hybrid mediation and arbitration hearings.

We can also provide for mediation or arbitration hearings at our other locations to help you resolve your disputes no matter where you are.

Main Office-Islandia
1377 Motor Parkway, Suite 204
Islandia, NY 11749

New York City
61 Broadway, Suite 2000
New York, NY 10006

41 Meeting House Ln A,
Southampton, NY 11968

126 North Main Street, Suite #4
East Hampton‚ NY 11937

Westhampton Beach
82 Main Street
Westhampton Beach, NY 11978